top of page
__JameChrittonBodyWork_Logo_Water.png

The Body Has More Stories Than Muscles

How Fascial Counterstrain Grew From a Simple Osteopathic Idea Into a Different Way of Looking at Pain

There is a moment that happens when you have been working with bodies long enough.

You put your hands on someone and realize the story you were taught is too small.

Maybe the person came in because their shoulder hurt.

Simple enough.

Except the shoulder had already been stretched and strengthened and massaged and injected and photographed from every conceivable angle, and still there it was—aching faithfully every morning like some old dog sitting at the foot of the bed.

So you put your hands on the shoulder.

And perhaps the shoulder is not the strangest thing you find.

There is tenderness along the neck.

Something guarded beneath the ribs.

A peculiar sensitivity along a nerve.

A tension somewhere that seems too distant to have anything to do with the original complaint.

And eventually you begin asking the question that has probably launched half the interesting discoveries in medicine:

What if we're looking at this the wrong way?

That question sits quietly underneath Brian Tuckey's 2025 paper on Fascial Counterstrain.

The paper describes how an old osteopathic technique, once concerned primarily with muscles and joints, gradually expanded into something considerably larger: an attempt to identify and treat protective dysfunction in many different kinds of tissue throughout the body.

And the journey from one idea to the other says something interesting about chronic pain.

Because bodies rarely behave as neatly as textbooks.

It Started With Tenderness

Long before Fascial Counterstrain, there was simply Strain–Counterstrain.

The original method is associated with osteopathic physician Lawrence Jones.

The story of Counterstrain begins, fittingly enough, with something almost accidental.

A patient was suffering.

Jones found that placing the person's body into a particular position of ease dramatically reduced the discomfort.

There was no heroic manipulation.

No forcing.

No cracking the body into submission.

Quite the opposite.

The body was moved toward comfort.

The strained tissue was shortened.

The protective response quieted.

And something changed.

From this observation came an elegant clinical idea:

Find a painful tender point associated with dysfunctional tissue.

Move the body into a position where that tender point softens.

Wait.

Then return slowly.

The treatment was almost suspiciously gentle.

And yet clinicians found it useful.

For decades, Counterstrain was understood primarily through the landscape of the musculoskeletal system—muscles, joints, ligaments, familiar anatomical things.

You hurt here.

We find the corresponding tender point.

We position the body.

The tissue relaxes.

Simple.

Except bodies have a habit of ruining simple theories.

The Map Kept Getting Bigger

Imagine being handed a map of California and being told that the entire world ends at the Nevada border.

For a while, the map works perfectly well.

You can find Oakland.

You can drive to Los Angeles.

You can wander north through the redwoods.

Then one day somebody keeps driving east.

The landscape continues.

That is essentially what happened with Counterstrain.

Over roughly two decades, Tuckey and colleagues began identifying patterns that appeared to extend beyond traditional musculoskeletal tissues.

The map kept getting bigger.

What began with muscle expanded toward fascia associated with arteries.

Veins.

Lymphatic structures.

Peripheral nerves.

Visceral tissues.

The membranes and connective tissues associated with the nervous system.

Structures connected with the brain and spinal cord.

The body suddenly looked less like a collection of orthopedic parts and more like an enormous web of tissues capable of reacting protectively to injury and inflammation.

The 2025 paper describes this expanded system as Fascial Counterstrain.

Its central proposition is ambitious:

Counterstrain may not simply be a technique for relaxing muscles.

It may be a method for identifying and reducing protective dysfunction within many different tissue systems. citeturn297481search0

And once you entertain that possibility, chronic pain begins looking different.

The Body Doesn't Know the Word “Orthopedic”

Walk through a hospital and everything has a department.

Neurology upstairs.

Orthopedics down the hall.

Gastroenterology somewhere around the corner.

Vascular medicine.

Cardiology.

Pain management.

Psychiatry.

Beautiful little territories with doors and specialties and billing codes.

The body has no idea any of these divisions exist.

A nerve travels through connective tissue beside an artery.

The artery runs beside a vein.

Lymphatic vessels move through the same neighborhood.

Muscles pull across fascial planes.

Organs hang from connective tissue.

The spinal cord lives inside membranes.

Every structure influences the environment of another structure.

There is only one landscape.

And inflammation does not carry a clipboard telling it which medical department it belongs to.

This is part of what makes the FCS model interesting.

Instead of asking only,

Which muscle is tight?

it asks,

Which tissue system appears to be behaving protectively?

That might still be muscle.

But it might also involve the connective tissue surrounding a nerve.

Or a vascular structure.

Or visceral fascia.

Or another region entirely.

The question gets larger.

And sometimes a larger question is exactly what a complicated patient needs.

Pain Is Not Always Where the Story Began

Anyone who has lived with chronic pain knows the peculiar geography of it.

It moves.

It spreads.

It develops weather.

One month it is the back.

Then there is burning down the leg.

Then headaches.

Then a shoulder that suddenly refuses to cooperate.

You begin with one problem and somehow acquire a constellation.

One explanation for this is sensitization.

The nervous system is not merely a wire carrying messages from injured tissue to the brain.

It learns.

It adapts.

It amplifies.

If danger signals continue arriving, the system can become increasingly responsive to them.

Eventually the alarm may become easier to trigger than it once was.

The house doesn't necessarily have more fires.

The smoke detector has become more sensitive.

Tuckey's paper places central sensitization among the scientific ideas relevant to Fascial Counterstrain's proposed mechanisms. It also discusses research concerning the contractile and proprioceptive properties of fascia and microvascular dysfunction. citeturn297481search0

And here the story becomes stranger.

Because fascia isn't dead wrapping paper around the important parts.

It is living tissue.

It contains cells.

It is innervated.

It participates in mechanical signaling.

It responds to inflammation and changes in its environment.

The sheet of connective tissue you once peeled away in anatomy lab because you were trying to get to the "real anatomy" turns out to have a story of its own.

Maybe the Tightness Is Protection

We often encounter tension and immediately declare war on it.

Stretch it.

Roll it.

Dig into it.

Release it.

Make it longer.

But what if some tension isn't simply an error?

What if it is protection?

Imagine spraining your ankle badly.

Your body doesn't ask permission before changing how you walk.

Muscles guard.

Weight shifts.

Movement becomes smaller.

Everything reorganizes around the injured region.

This is intelligent.

You want this response.

The difficulty begins when the protective response persists after it has stopped being useful.

The war ended, but the soldiers never received the letter.

This is one way of understanding the basic Counterstrain idea.

Rather than battling the guarding directly, move the tissue toward ease.

Give the nervous system information that the threatened structure no longer requires the same degree of protection.

And wait.

There is something almost philosophical about this.

Most treatments approach dysfunction by adding force.

Counterstrain approaches it by temporarily removing demand.

It does not shout at the tissue.

It lowers the volume of the room.

The Strange Geography of Tender Points

One of the defining features of Fascial Counterstrain is its diagnostic use of tender points.

The practitioner searches the body for small, unusually sensitive areas associated within the FCS system with different anatomical structures and tissue systems.

This creates something like a map.

Not a map drawn from where the patient says the pain is.

A map drawn from how the body responds to examination.

And the two maps aren't always identical.

Someone might arrive talking about the knee.

The examination may lead somewhere else.

Someone arrives complaining about the neck.

Another system may appear more prominent.

This is one reason the method can feel unusual to patients accustomed to treatment focused exclusively on the painful region.

The painful place is taken seriously.

But it is not automatically assumed to be the entire story.

The body is questioned more broadly.

And the answers come through tenderness.

Treatment by Doing Less

The actual treatment can look almost comically uneventful.

A practitioner finds a tender point.

The body is positioned carefully.

Small adjustments are made.

The tissue is unloaded.

The point becomes less sensitive.

And then everybody waits.

No grimacing.

No heroic suffering.

No practitioner leaning their entire body weight through an elbow.

Sometimes the most dramatic thing happening in the room is that nothing dramatic is happening at all.

This is the great paradox of indirect treatment:

You change the system by moving away from resistance rather than deeper into it.

In Fascial Counterstrain, this basic principle inherited from classic Counterstrain is applied across a much broader anatomical model.

The paper describes the method as an indirect, non-force approach intended to identify and treat dysfunction involving both peripheral and central nervous-system-related tissues as well as somatic, vascular, visceral, and neuromeningeal structures. citeturn297481search0turn297481search7

It's a long way from simply rubbing a tight muscle.

Then Comes the Patient Nobody Knows What to Do With

Every theory eventually encounters the person sitting in the treatment room.

The person who doesn't care about the elegance of your mechanism.

They just want their life back.

Tuckey's paper includes a case involving a patient with complex postoperative pain and complex regional pain syndrome who had not responded adequately to multiple previous medical interventions.

The case is included to demonstrate how the Fascial Counterstrain framework might be applied clinically, and the paper reports rapid subjective, objective, and functional improvement following treatment. citeturn297481search0

A case report cannot prove that a treatment will work broadly.

One patient is one patient.

There is no control group hiding behind the curtain.

No case report should be mistaken for the final word.

But cases matter because sometimes they show us where to look next.

Nearly every new road begins because somebody walked far enough to notice that the existing map was incomplete.

A Technique Becoming a Hypothesis

This is what I find most interesting about Fascial Counterstrain.

Not that it has solved chronic pain.

It hasn't.

Not that every proposed mechanism has been conclusively established.

It hasn't.

The science is still developing.

What interests me is that a manual therapy technique has gradually become something closer to a physiological hypothesis.

What if persistent pain sometimes involves more than injured muscles and joints?

What if inflammation changes the mechanical environment of connective tissue?

What if microcirculation matters?

What if fascia participates actively in protective responses?

What if some seemingly unrelated symptoms are connected because nerves, vessels, viscera, lymphatics, and musculoskeletal tissues share the same continuous internal landscape?

What if touching the body differently allows us to ask different questions?

Those are interesting questions.

And good medicine has always advanced because somebody became dissatisfied with the questions everyone else had agreed to ask.

What My Hands Have Taught Me

When I began studying bodywork, I wanted answers.

I wanted anatomy to behave like geography.

This muscle starts here.

It attaches there.

This nerve travels here.

This movement means that.

Find the restriction.

Fix the restriction.

Next patient.

Years of putting my hands on actual human beings ruined that beautiful simplicity.

Because people arrive carrying car accidents and surgeries and heartbreak and desk jobs and old ankle sprains and infections and sleepless children and years of bracing themselves against things no anatomy textbook could possibly diagram.

And their bodies adapt.

Brilliantly.

Strangely.

Sometimes excessively.

The longer I do this work, the less interested I become in asking:

Where is the bad tissue?

And the more interested I become in asking:

What is this body trying to protect?

Which system is asking for attention?

What happens if we stop fighting the body's response long enough to understand it?

That is what Fascial Counterstrain has added to my work.

A larger map.

The willingness to look beyond the sore muscle.

The suspicion that the body might be making sense even when its symptoms don't.

And an appreciation for one of the strangest lessons in manual therapy:

Sometimes you don't get a frightened system to let go by pushing harder.

Sometimes you listen.

You find the place that is shouting.

You take the pressure off.

And for a little while you give the body nothing to fight against.

Then you wait to see which road opens.

The Road Is Still Being Built

Fascial Counterstrain is still an evolving method, and its proposed physiological mechanisms require more rigorous independent investigation.

That distinction matters.

A compelling model is not the same thing as scientific proof.

A dramatic case is not the same thing as a randomized clinical trial.

And a practitioner's experience, however convincing, cannot replace good research.

But research itself begins with observations.

Something happens repeatedly enough that somebody asks why.

A technique changes.

A hypothesis forms.

Scientists measure.

Others challenge it.

The map gets corrected.

And that is perhaps the most interesting place to be:

Not at the end of the road declaring that everything has been discovered,

but somewhere out past the familiar signs,

looking at a landscape we thought we understood,

and realizing there may be considerably more country ahead.

James Chritton is a Certified Rolfer® and bodyworker practicing in Oakland and Lafayette, California. His work integrates Fascial Counterstrain, Rolfing® Structural Integration, and somatic movement therapy, with a focus on chronic pain, movement restriction, and complex patterns of tension.

To learn more or schedule a session: jameschritton.com | 925-878-1441

Further Reading

Brian Tuckey. Fascial Counterstrain: A Methodological Advancement in Indirect Osteopathic Manipulation. International Journal of Osteopathic Medicine. 2025;58:100789.

Tuckey et al. Impaired Lymphatic Drainage and Interstitial Inflammatory Stasis in Chronic Musculoskeletal and Idiopathic Pain Syndromes. Frontiers in Pain Research. 2021.

bottom of page